The celtics, as emphasized by the media, have a lot of flexibility with it’s cap room, team friendly contracts and draft capital. Danny Ainge completely played the Nets and for that have a very bright future. But there have been rumbles lately about the celtics interest in trading the first overall pick to the Chicago Bulls for Jimmy Butler. While I understand this, I would have to say no to that and here is why.

I will not deny that Jimmy butler is a very good player because clearly he is. He is a great defender and has turned himself into a very good offensive player. But I think trading for him would be a mistake. The first thing is while Butler is a good player, I would not call him a great player and I would definitely not call him a player that you build your team around. But more then that, if you give up the first pick for Butler, the Celtics would be declaring that they are in win now mode. But the thing is, against the Cavs, even if they did add Butler, I wouldn’t give them that much more of a chance then I would today. So if they traded for Butler, they would be capping themselves because Butler is kind of who he is and I don’t know how much better he’s going to get. While Getting Markelle Fultz is riskier, Fultz has superstar potential and you can build a championship team around Markelle potentially, while Butler would never be that guy for the Celtics. Butler would be the 2nd or 3rd best player on a championship team and is the 1st pick worth that? The Other Veteran I have heard Rumbles about is Paul George. I wouldn’t trade for Butler, but I get it. But with George? I would not understand that at all. He has one year left on his contract, and it is well known on his intentions. So basically, they would be trading the first overall pick for a one year rental, saying again that they are in win now mode. Like Butler, George has proven he cannot lead a team to the finals while being the best player, so doing that would be dumb.
Overall, while George and Butler are very good players, the value of the first overall pick means you have to get a superstar who can lead a championship team. And I don’t think Butler or George can be that guy that gets them over the top.